July 3, 2026 · 5 min
TradeDiscipline vs Edgewonk: psychology journal vs discipline coach (2026)
Edgewonk is the reference for psychology-focused traders, and at $197/year all-inclusive it's one of the most affordable premium journals. If you're comparing it with TradeDiscipline, you're already asking the right question: both products believe your P&L problem is a behavior problem. Here's where they differ.
Prices and features as observed in July 2026 on each product's public website.
The quick comparison
| TradeDiscipline | Edgewonk | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | €14.99/month (Plus), free tier | $197/year, one plan |
| Emotional tracking | ✓ per-trade emotions + edge by emotion | ✓ Tiltmeter |
| Cost of mistakes in € | ✓ capital leaks, quantified per habit | — (patterns shown, not priced) |
| AI analysis | ✓ daily, against your written strategy | Edge Finder AI: weekly report |
| AI coach chat | ✓ with long-term memory of your commitments | — |
| Real-time intervention | ✓ stop-trading guards, tilt push alerts | — (post-session reflection) |
| Broker auto-sync | ✓ MT4/MT5, cTrader, NinjaTrader, TradingView, Tradovate (Plus) + CSV and screenshot import | — (file import only) |
| Custom metrics | Fixed, discipline-focused | ✓ 50+ customizable, 20 custom slots |
| Mobile | PWA (installable) | — |
| Languages | FR, EN, DE, ES | EN |
Where Edgewonk is genuinely stronger
If you love building your own statistics (custom metrics, custom classifications, deep manual reflection), Edgewonk gives you 50+ configurable metrics and rewards the effort. Its one-price-for-everything model is also admirably simple.
Where TradeDiscipline wins
Edgewonk describes your psychology. TradeDiscipline prices it and interrupts it.
- Euros, not adjectives. Our capital-leaks block tells you "revenge trading cost you €480 this month" and draws the equity curve you'd have if you had followed your plan. Naming a pattern is step one; seeing its price is what changes behavior.
- Daily AI, not weekly. Edge Finder sends a weekly report. With TradeDiscipline you can run an analysis every day (Plus), and its coach chat remembers your commitments from last week, and calls out relapses.
- Real time. Tilt push alerts and stop-trading guards act during the session, not in Sunday's report.
- No manual homework. Broker auto-sync means the journal fills itself; Edgewonk requires file imports and manual upkeep.
Which one is for you?
Choose Edgewonk if you enjoy deep manual journaling, want maximum metric customization, and prefer a one-time yearly price.
Choose TradeDiscipline if you want the psychology work done for you: quantified in euros, surfaced daily, and interrupted live when you tilt. Try it free, no credit card required.
Turn theory into practice
Create my account