July 3, 2026 · 5 min
TradeDiscipline vs FocusPips: two French AI trading journals compared (2026)
FocusPips and TradeDiscipline share the same conviction: most traders don't need more indicators, they need to see where they lose money. So how do the two products actually differ? Honest comparison below.
Prices and features as observed in July 2026 on each product's public website.
The quick comparison
| TradeDiscipline | FocusPips | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Plus €14.99/mo · Premium €29.99/mo (€269.90/yr) | Basic free · Premium €290/yr (~€24.17/mo) |
| AI coach | ✓ chat with long-term memory of your commitments | ✓ Atlas chat (5 questions free, unlimited Premium) |
| Cost of mistakes in € | ✓ automatic capital-leaks block on the dashboard | via questions to the AI chat |
| "What if I'd followed my plan?" | ✓ counterfactual discipline curve | — |
| Candle-by-candle backtesting | — | ✓ (Premium) |
| Trade replay | — | ✓ |
| Real-time guards & tilt push alerts | ✓ | — |
| Broker sync | MT4/MT5, cTrader, NinjaTrader, Tradovate + CSV | MT4/MT5, cTrader + CSV |
| Community & gamification | ✓ leaderboard, challenges, streaks | — |
| Daily AI macro briefing | ✓ (Premium) | — (economic calendar, COT, seasonality) |
| Languages | FR, EN, DE, ES | FR |
Where FocusPips is genuinely stronger
If candle-by-candle backtesting and trade replay are central to your process, FocusPips has both built in. It also offers market-context data (COT positioning, seasonality) that TradeDiscipline doesn't carry.
Where TradeDiscipline wins
- The mistake report comes to you. Capital leaks are computed automatically and displayed on your dashboard in euros, with the counterfactual curve showing where your account would be with your plan followed. No need to ask the right question to a chatbot.
- A coach with memory. Our AI remembers what you committed to last session and tells you when you break it. A conversation, not a Q&A.
- Real-time protection. Stop-trading guards, prop-firm challenge limits, tilt push alerts: during the session, not after.
- Four languages and a community (leaderboard, community challenges, streaks) if consistency motivates you socially.
Which one is for you?
Choose FocusPips if replay and candle-by-candle backtesting are the core of your routine.
Choose TradeDiscipline if you want your discipline priced in euros automatically, a coach that remembers, and guardrails that act in real time, all in four languages. Try it free.
Turn theory into practice
Create my account